Subscribe to the YouDecide2007 newsletter






 
Home arrow Opinion Archive arrow Story Boards
Story Boards

By Graham Young,


Two Brisbane billboards tell more than they perhaps mean to about the federal election campaign.

Liberal Campbell Newman used an ancient form of advertising when he successfully ran for Lord Mayor of Brisbane - the billboard. Large pictures of Newman declaring he wouldn't stand for "gridlock" dominated Brisbane's arterial roads. He was everywhere. He owned the place.

Now it's Kevin Rudd who appears to own the place, on some of the very same billboards, as this picture, taken yesterday on Shafston Avenue, Kangaroo Point, the approach to the Story Bridge and in Rudd's own electorate of Griffith shows.

rudd_billboard_blog.jpg

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

  It's a strong and handsome billboard, dressed in the patriotic red, white and blue that the Liberal Party also used to think it "owned". If there is one thing that the Labor Party stands for, it is Kevin Rudd, and you get the impression that Rudd is quite happy about that.

It's a statement about the future, with a link to www.kevin07.com.au,  and the authorisation along the bottom suggests that its future encompasses the election campaign. There's a slight bolshiness about it. The background is actually the flag, but without the Union Jack - the Republic is alive and well. Kevin's definitely a man of the future.

The second billboard is on Brisbane's inner-north, at the Normanby Fiveways. It's low rent compared to Campbell Newman's effort 4 years ago in this spot where he had a massive billboard on the other side of the road.

 liberal_billboard_blog.jpg

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

This one is much smaller, over the carpet shop, and the billboard owner's exhortation that "You can be here" suggests it's not the prime spot on the corner. This sign's also got a flag, a Union Jack, but no southern cross, and no leader. Whatever the Liberal Party stands for, as far as this sign knows, it is not John Howard. (Actually, you can just discern the southern cross in the second flag which is part of the Liberal logo.)

It is about messages. Kevin's sign is short on words, but this one asserts a conviction, which is pretty much in line with what its leader stands for anyway. The Jack, and the wavy edge on the top of the flag, make it look dated, something circa the Second World War. And it doesn't have an authorisation, which means it will very probably become illegal when the election is called. This sign doesn't have much of a future at all - perhaps the budget only stretched to a month or so.

The slogan also doesn't appear to exist on the federal Liberal Party's website, but it is the banner heading on the one belonging to the Queensland Liberals. It's possible this is a local effort.

When campaigns falter in the Liberal Party they tend to fray, and everyone thinks they know best. This presentation on the New South Wales site suggests that someone there thinks this is a good idea, but it's certainly not part of a unified coherent message, at least not yet.

These two signs pretty much sum the campaigns up. Labor's is about leadership, Kevin, and the future; it's well-funded, but it doesn't want to say too much. The Liberal's is about conviction and doing what's right, but it doesn't want to talk about the leader, looks dated, and lacks funds.

The only thing they have in common really is the colours.

 

 

 

 


   

Users' Comments  RSS feed comment

Display 5 of 7 comments

Reading the signs

By: jasonw (Registered ) on 13-09-2007 23:26

Graham - lovely opinion piece connecting the local with the national. The "semiotics" of this (as we used to say in communications studies) are telling, as you say. I wonder if you (or any other readers) have any suggestions as to a viable Liberal campaign slogan/communications strategy going forward into the election?

» Report this comment to administrator

 

Reading the tea leaves

By: Katie (Registered ) on 14-09-2007 00:49

Good piece Graham- I will also be trying to find out what the libs have in store on the slogan angle. Kevin 007 is a strange one for Lab but that billboard is alot more "now" than the Libs.  
 
I think the Libs should go for "tried and true " as their slogan. However it could be changed by Labor to "tired and blue." I also think that they want to knock leadership issues on head and go team with something like "The winning team", "Australia's best chance", "Back the Best", "Simply the best", "Go you good thing" or "Team Liberal"

» Report this comment to administrator

 

What Signs

By: Bauple (Registered ) on 14-09-2007 03:05

As a candidate for the Greens, I would just like the funding to afford one of these signs. Ours would have a message about climate change which would be old and dated since we started talking about it 20 years ago and also now because everybody else is now talking about it?

» Report this comment to administrator

 

Campaign suggestions

By: grahamy (Registered ) on 14-09-2007 11:49

I've probably got a few sugsestions for the Coalition, but I think I'll do it in a separate opinion piece for OLO and UD07. This is one election where I don't have too many suggestions for Labor, although I think this presidential style of campaign is horribly dangerous in the Australian context, but when you're this far ahead, risk is a relatively meaningless concept! 
 
Glad I got the semiotics right Jason. I did it in French for one semester back in the '70s. Wasn't my most glorious academic moment.

» Report this comment to administrator

 

Signage is safe Labor seat

By: gasbo (Registered ) on 17-09-2007 06:01

The image atop this item also appears at Ipwich's Bundamba Queenland racecourse (for equine), I wonder if Kevi has put the mockas on the horse racing industry. Psst only jokin'

» Report this comment to administrator

 

Display 5 of 7 comments



Add your comment
Only registered users can comment an article. Please login or register.

More comments...



mXcomment 1.0.2 © 2007-2008 - visualclinic.fr
License Creative Commons - Some rights reserved
 
< Prev   Next >