Subscribe to the YouDecide2007 newsletter






 
Home arrow Opinion Archive arrow No more Labor heartland?
No more Labor heartland?

By kiley gaffney,


Growing up, my family worshipped at the altar of unionism. My parents embraced ‘working class’ as an active social position not as a step on the aspirational treadmill. In those days and in the areas where I lived, it was nothing special. It was a given that everyone was in a union and voted Labor, manning factories and building sites and marching or striking when the need arose. Briefly my father had run (or tried to run) on a communist ticket in far north Queensland but failed dismally and quickly came back to the Labor fold. Labor had a heartland and my family was deeply in it. I remember both parents screaming at the television as the media backlash against the strikes of my Queensland childhood painted unionists as troublemakers ruining the lives of the average man. Who was the average man if it wasn’t us? But at some stage in my adult years of conservative rule, the myth of the working class seems like just a bittersweet reminder of a collective imaginary well past its time. My family and those of my childhood friends had found some comfort in the ideals of unionism, the solidarity of a community that drew strength from its limited power in their social and economic domains. Someone was interested in what was best for us collectively, and ‘the greater good’ that we were all accountable to, the moral authority of politics, meant that sometimes things didn’t necessarily go our way.

But allegiances have changed. What has happened to these familial political links, these bloodlines that Labor has depended upon to keep its numbers? In my electorate the changes are palpable. Despite the obvious element of the reflexive oppositional voting patterns brought about after long term leadership by one party – the “anyone’s better than John Howard” response - I am seeing waves of old school Labor voters shifting to the Greens or independents, who now represent the policies they feel best represent the needs of a ‘greater good’. Even those that will vote Labor do so cynically; Kevin Rudd might not be the best man for the job but he’s surely better than anything Liberal has to offer. Of course, academically I understand the shifting domain of politics – ‘neoliberalism’, the third way, globalization, the politics of fear, etc – but when I see my family’s political allegiances faltering, these shifts seem localised, endemic and unchangeable. Labor no longer represents the unions that have held their community together. Labor now engages with centrist politics to such a degree that my parents no longer see themselves in their policies or rhetoric. My three brothers as union delegates have now lost faith in the power of governmental representation, in a politics of numbers that extends beyond industrial divisions and workplace reform. The truest violence for them is the dissolution of the belief in a working class. They feel powerless and misrepresented. It’s a hard path to walk with them. They are finding it hard to let go of Labor despite the cynicism of their allegiance. How many like them will vote Labor as an antidote to Howard and how many will vote as a reflex?

   

Users' Comments  RSS feed comment

Display 5 of 11 comments

labor heartland?

By: Spider (Registered ) on 29-09-2007 09:00

That was very well expressed. I too grew up in a staunch Labor family. Growing up, all I heard was how Labor is the only party that looks after the working man but when it was my first time to vote, I started to look around for myself. 
 
My letters to the political parties as a new and interested voter was ignored by all political parties but the Liberals. All I received was a letter from Andrew Peacock whose letter said I would find their policies of which I found none but hey, they atleast responded so I voted for him. 
 
Then came the state election between Greiner and Carr which saw a parliament held to ransom by three very egotistical Independent members. I looked around and saw how much work had been done for the western suburbs of Sydney. I listened to the ALP say that they only look after the western suburbs but it not the ALP that fixed the broken down railway, or put money into hospitals and more. 
 
Once again, it was only the Liberals who responded to any of my approaches so yet again, I voted Liberal who were the only one's who wanted to respond.

» Report this comment to administrator

 

labor heartland part 2

By: Spider (Registered ) on 29-09-2007 09:02

In 1992, I decided to join a political party but I didn't knwo who to join. 
 
The Greens were a Tasmanian party, the Democrats hung up on me, when I visited my local state member who was ALP, his staff told me to get out or I would be charged for trespassing. The state seat adjacent then held by Liberal, Guy Matheson, happily took down my details. I received mail from his office, state office and the Young Liberals. Guess who I joined not knowing anything of politics?

» Report this comment to administrator

 

left of labor

By: kiley (Registered ) on 30-09-2007 06:51

Thanks Spider.  
 
My point was that Labor had shifted so far right that they were now were Liberal was ten years ago. I'd never vote Liberal. Ever. 
 
My politics remain staunchly left. It's just the party I once voted for shifted right.

» Report this comment to administrator

 

understood

By: Spider (Registered ) on 01-10-2007 09:20

I understood your point and your point is correct. I just wanted to give an opinion from a person who also grew up in Labor Land who would, with all want, vote for the ALP were they to do anything that they claim to be but they aren't.

» Report this comment to administrator

 

No more labour heartland

By: Denice (Registered ) on 03-10-2007 20:07

This is how I grew up, with my parents telling me the ALP was the workers' party, the only party that looked after the ordinary man in the street, etc - the sentiments expressed mirror exactly my experience growing up. However, in later life - starting with Gough Whitlam and followed by Bob Hawke, Paul Keating and Wayne Goss - my parents became disillusioned with the ALP and began to seriously question that their "beloved party" (as my father used to say) was still representative of the worker. My father cast his last vote a few days before he died of cancer and he very happily admitted he wanted to do so because for the first time in his life he was not going to vote ALP but voted Liberal instead, such was his disappointment in the party which supposedly was for the worker but which, in his opinion, had failed the worker.

» Report this comment to administrator

 

Display 5 of 11 comments



Add your comment
Only registered users can comment an article. Please login or register.

More comments...



mXcomment 1.0.2 © 2007-2008 - visualclinic.fr
License Creative Commons - Some rights reserved
 
< Prev   Next >